Determining your Food & Beverage Budget

Choosing your food courses:

During a typical event, many people include the following “courses”:

  1. Appetizers

  2. A main meal

  3. Dessert

Depending on the event, some people also consider:

  • A rehearsal dinner

  • Late-night snacks (served during the event after dessert)

  • A farewell brunch

Catered food is typically calculated per person, so your guest count is the key determinant of your overall food cost.


The role of catering staff:

Having catering staff set-up and serve the food (either as a buffet or plated meal) costs more, but it also removes a significant amount of work from friends and family, who otherwise spend a lot of time in the kitchen before and/or during the event itself.

Catering staff is typically either calculated as an additional cost “per person” or as a 15-20% “service charge”. So basically take whatever you’re spending on the food itself and multiply it by 1.2 to estimate the cost of adding service staff.


How to select a food & drink plan within your budget:

Start by determining your overall budget for food and beverages, and then divide by your total guest count. This number will give you your total per person cost. This number should include all of the food and drinks you plan to serve, including appetizers, dessert, and beverages.

Total cost / person = (Total F&B Budget) ÷ (Total guest count)

Once you know your max cost per person, you’ll want to piece together your appetizers, dinner menu, desserts, drinks, and any extras so that your total stays under this value.

This may include a combination of DIYs, caterers, food trucks, and other professional vendors (like a baker or unique snack station).

One of the trickiest parts here is figuring out your drink budget, which we dive into more on our Drinks page!

Some Great Food Choices

Sterk’s Catering

(440) 775-0028 
580 W. Lorain St., Oberlin, OH 44074  

Four service level options for all food packages ranging from self-serve “drop catering” to full service complete with serving staff, real china plates, and stainless silverware.

Classic buffet:

  • 2-3 entrees + 2 starches + 2 vegetables + 1-2 salads

  • Food only (self-serve): $16/p

  • Servers: $21-$23/p

  • Servers + china: $28/p

  • Dessert: $2.75/p

Other offerings:

  • Pasta bar: $14-$22/p

  • Fajita & taco bar: $17-$25/p

  • BBQ: $23-$31/p

  • Other options: Grilled chicken & ribs; Luau; Pig roast; Steak Fry

Fligner’s Market

(440) 244-5173 
1854 Broadway Avenue, Lorain, OH 44052 

Self-serve and full service options.

Food only (self serve):

  • 3 entrees + 3 sides + salad + rolls for 30 people $428, then $143 for additional increments of 10 people

  • 2 entrees + 2 sides + salad + rolls for 30 people $368, then $123 for additional increments of 10 people

Classic buffets with servers:

  • Choice of 3 entrees + 3 sides + salad + rolls: $863 for 50 people, then $173 for each additional 10 people

  • Choice of 2 entrees + 2 sides + salad + rolls: $763 for 50 people, then $153 for each additional 10 people

  • PLUS 22% service fee to cover servers

  • China: $5.50/p

Other offerings:

  • Taco bar: $290/25 people

  • Pasta bar: $240/25 people

  • Hamburger/hotdog bar: $290/24 people

  • Baked potato bar: $180/25 people

  • Appetizer trays available (fruit, veggie, cheese, shrimp, bruschetta, meats, etc..): $30(ish)-$60(ish) per tray

  • Fancier apps and desserts available at additional cost per person.

City Barbeque

Avon location: (440) 230-8563
35495 Chester Rd, Avon, OH 44011

Self-serve and full service options. For their Delivery & Set-up level of service, prices range from $15.50- $27/person.

  • Cheaper packages include your choice of 1 meat and 2 sides

  • More expensive options include up to 2 meats, 3 sides, and a dessert

  • Other options: Appetizer trays, taco and nacho bars, a la carte meats (including ribs), vegetarian options, and more

  • Full service staffed events - contact them for a quote.

Other Affordable Local Options

Lorenzo’s Pizzeria (Italian food, Oberlin)
Aladdin’s Eatery Catering (Lebanese food, Oberlin)
Olive Garden Catering (Italian food, Elyria)
Chipotle Catering (Mexican food, Amherst)

Some Options…

Appetizers:

  • Nacho bar

    • City BBQ: $3/p

  • Popcorn bar

    • DIY: $1-2/p

  • Fruit, veggie, cheese & cracker, and meat trays

    • Fligners: ~ $1-$1.20/p per tray type

    • City BBQ: ~ $3/p per tray type

    • Sterks Picnic (App/Main combo): $20/p, includes veggie tray + fruit

  • Tasting cups (ex: soup + cracker stick; hummus + pita + celery)

    • DIY: $1-2/p

    • Professional caterer: $3-4/p

  • Skewers (ex: cheese + veggie + meat)

    • Fligners: Swedish meatballs $1/p

  • Dips + dippers (ex: spinach & artichoke dip; warm buffalo ranch chicken dip)

    • DIY: $1-2/p

    • City BBQ: Hot chicken dip $3/p

Mains:

  • Classic buffet

    • Fligners: Starts at $10.25/p

    • Sterks: Starts at $16/p

  • Taco / fajita bars

    • Fligners: $10.25/p*

    • Sterks: Starts at $17/p

  • Pasta bars

    • Fligners: $8.50/p*

    • Sterks: Starts at $14/p

  • BBQ pulled pork / shredded chicken

    • City BBQ: Starts at $15.50/p

  • Burgers & hotdogs

    • Sterks: $20/p (app/main combo)

    • Fligners: $9.15/p*

  • Chili bar

    • Fligners: $5.25/p*

  • Rice / noodle bowl bar

  • Food trucks

  • Soups & flatbreads

*Fligners prepared foods are available in increments of 25 people.

Desserts:

  • Classic multi-tiered wedding cake

  • Small “cut cake”

  • Sheet cake

    • Fligners: $0.50-$1/serving

    • City BBQ: Triple chocolate cake $2.33/p (24 servings/cake)

  • Cupcakes

  • Cookies / Brownies

    • Fligners: $50/72 cookies

    • Fligners: $50/96 brownie bites

    • Sterks: $2.75/p

    • City BBQ: $45/24 cookies

  • Cobblers and Pies

    • Sterks: Pie or strudel $2.75/p

    • City BBQ: Cobbler with whipped cream $3.50/p (16 servings/pan)

  • S’mores (over an open bonfire at Carawood Lake!)

  • Ice-cream

  • Candy bar

Figuring Out your Beverage Needs

This is one of the most complicated parts of a budget to estimate because there are so many different options and variables.

Use the information below as a guide, and adjust based on your preferences, overall budget, and what and how much your guests like to drink.


How many drinks should you plan on serving?

Use this formula to estimate the number of drinks you’ll need so you don’t over- or under-buy.

Total drinks needed = (# of drinking guests) × (hours of reception) x (buffer)


A few notes about the formula:

  • Count only adults who drink alcohol. A decent default is 80% of adult guests, but adjust this if you know your people skew higher or lower.

  • Guests drink faster in the first hour of a reception (cocktail hour ≈ 1.5–2 drinks), but slower after dinner. The 1 drink/hour average washes out over a 5- to 6-hour reception.

  • People drink more during hot outdoor summer weddings, so increase your total drinks needed by ~10–15% and double or even triple your water. (At Carawood Lake, we have municipal water with a pleasant taste right out of the tap. Many of our hosts simply fill carafes or drink dispensers with tap water and add a garnish like sliced lemons or cucumbers rather than buy gallons and gallons of bottled water.)

  • A good buffer number to use is 1.2, which gives yourself a 20% buffer. To reduce this to a 10% buffer, multiply by 1.1; to increase to a 30% buffer, multiply by 1.3, etc.

For example, with 100 guests, assume about 80 drinkers. Over 5 hours, that equals 400 drinks + 20% buffer ≈ 480 drinks needed.


What do you want to serve?

The simple truth is that more choices = higher cost. Limiting options can save significant money. But you also know what your guests like to drink. So consider your options…


How much should you buy?

Once you decide what types of drinks you want, you’ll determine how much of each item you should buy.

Take the number of total drinks you need and start splitting it up based on what you want to serve.

For example, in our 100 person wedding above, we calculated we would want about 480 drinks. The dropdown menus in this section break down the calculations and total estimated costs, based on what you plan to serve.


What about bartenders?

You’ll definitely want a bartender if you are having a full bar. Anything below that and it’s up to you.

Guests are generally pretty good at serving themselves beer/seltzer, pre-mixed cocktails in a drink dispenser, and non-alcoholic beverages. A bartender in these settings is really helping to control consumption - making sure no one is over-served, and that all the options are cold and “fully stocked” at the bar at all times.

If you decide to hire a bartender, you’ll want to plan on 1 bartender per ~50 drinking guests for a full bar and 1 bartender per ~75 guests for Limited Signature Bar or beer/wine only bars.

The cost is generally $25-50/hr per bartender. So for the hypothetical 100 person party with a full bar, you’d probably want 2 bartenders for 4-6 hrs = $25-50/hr x 4-6 hrs x 2 bartenders = $200-$600